Origami Copyright Sign by Morisue Kei "Origami Copyright: How to Play Nice!" - origamiexpressions.com

Everyone has the right to the protection of the moral and material interests resulting from any scientific, literary or artistic production of which he is the author.
United Nations, Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Origami Copyright….really….?

Copyright in any creative field is often a controversial subject, particularly in today’s internet age where anyone can create and publish resources online. Origami is no exception in this – you don’t have to look very hard to find diagrams, video instructions or photographs that have been copied and published online without the permission of their creator. It is particularly difficult with origami, as copyright will apply in several ways.

This page sets out why I believe respecting copyright in origami is important, and my understanding of how copyright applies to origami. I am not an expert in law, so please don’t take my advice as legal counsel. Copyright law is complex and differs around the world, but this is how I understand the commonly accepted role of copyright within the origami community.

 

Origami Expressions and Origami Copyright

To begin with, here is my stance:

It is vital for the future of origami that copyright is upheld and respected. It is not just a matter of legality, or personal ethics, it is also the only way to support innovation and growth of origami as an art form.

This site does not, and never will infringe upon copyright in origami, or condone those that do.  All resources hosted on, or linked to from this site are – to the best of my knowledge – either:

  • My own work
  • Traditional and in the public domain
  • Reproduced with the permission of the copyright holder, with acknowledgements

 

Does Origami Copyright prevent innovation?

It is often said that copyright stifles innovation in creative arts, that it should be abolished, and that copyright infringement ‘democratises’ creativity by making everything available to everyone. I believe that this is not only untrue, but that copyright infringement actually damages innovation in origami.

It is difficult to believe that copyright has held the growth of origami back. This art form has developed dramatically over the last forty or fifty years. Much more complex models have been produced thanks to the development of sophisticated design techniques. Other creators have focused on interpretation and imagination rather than detail. The result of these developments is that the models at the cutting edge of origami today are beautiful, dramatic and awe-inspiring.

Ignoring copyright in origami might be a way of ‘democratising’ the design process, making it available to all, but it sacrifices expertise and detailed knowledge. Depth of skill is lost and the growth of origami as an art form will slow.

RatInnovating and producing new designs in origami at this level can be time-consuming. It takes great skill, built up over time. The late Eric Joisel used to say that it took him thirty years to come up with a new design (such as his rat, shown here and folded by me), because that was how long he had been doing origami and how long he had been honing & developing his skills. Unless designers are recognised, rewarded and paid for the time and effort they invest in their creativity, they will be unable to do so. It will simply be economically unsustainable.

There isn’t a shortage of models that can be folded with the permission of the creator today, and no need to break copyright. There are more designs to make than ever before, and instructions are available through a range of channels, including books, magazines, videos, origami societies, and websites like this one. I recognise that not everybody in the world has the same level of access that I enjoy in the UK, but even in places where that access is more limited, there are still options available – even if that is posting a letter to the designer requesting diagrams. There really isn’t a valid reason for infringing origami copyright today – only personal choice.

 

How Origami Copyright works

So having set out why I believe origami copyright is important, this is my understanding of how copyright law generally applies to origami – even allowing for differences in the legal position  around the world. As I said above, I’m not a lawyer, so please don’t take this as legal advice!

 

Traditional origami models

Traditional CraneThere is a wide range of simple traditional origami models, such as this crane. These designs are not subject to copyright and can be used and re-used for any personal or commercial purpose. Diagrams showing how to make them however, are a creative work and subject to copyright (see diagrams below).

 

Non-traditional models

Any completed model which isn’t traditional is subject to copyright. The original designer retains sole discretion of what can or cannot be done with that design. The copyright for the Fiery Dragon model depicted here for example, is owned by Kade Chan. If you fold a copy of that model from a book, a video, or a taught class, that is exactly what you have made – a copy. Personal use is permitted, but commercial use is unlikely to be covered without the permission of the designer. Check first before selling it.

 

 

Diagrams

Fiery Dragon 1Somebody has created those diagrams, so they have the copyright for them. Although a folding sequence cannot be copyrighted, diagrams are pictures of the folding sequence. They are a creative work, just as much as the final model, so the same rules apply. You can use the diagrams to make the model for personal use. Commercial use is unlikely to be permitted without permission of the copyright holder. You may not reproduce them, or sell them (eg by compiling them with others into a different book and reselling them). That includes the diagrams for traditional models on this site, which I created!

 

Videos

Hsi-Min Tai's Origami DolphinThe same restrictions apply to videos as for origami diagrams. The person or people who made the video hold the copyright for it. If you want to make a video showing how to fold the model, you should ask the designer’s permission to do so – as a matter of ethics and politeness as much as anything else. For example, a while ago I posted a blog featuring Hsi-Min Tai’s dolphin and somebody asked me for video instructions. I said I would do so, provided the designer gave permission. They did, so I will be making this video soon.

 

Crease Patterns

These are just another form of diagram – the creases that make up the model if it is unfolded.  They are subject to the same copyright as other diagrams, and the finished work.

 

Photos

Like any other photograph, the photographer owns the copyright of a photo of an origami model. If you take a picture of a design and use it on something like this blog or instagram, you should credit the designer of the original model. If you use somebody else’s photo, you should credit the photographer as well as the designer. As you can see, the photos on this site are taken by me and all models are credited in the blog text.

 

Educational or Charitable Use

This is a bit of a grey area! Some designers permit educational or charitable use of their designs, some don’t.  The solution is pretty simple though: unless you can see somewhere (eg their website) that they have expressly permitted educational or charitable use, assume they haven’t and ask first.

 

Origami Copyright and Ethics

One of the most respected origami creators in the world, Joseph Wu has frequently posted on his facebook page about the vitriolic abuse and insults he gets online from people who are offended that he does not make diagrams available for more of his models. He shouldn’t have to put up with this – it’s unfair, unpleasant, and unnecessary. I would love to try my hand at some of Wu’s designs, but I respect his choice and his right to make that decision.

In the end it is  not just a matter of law, it’s also integrity.  Do you want to be the person that contributes to origami and helps it grow over the long term, or takes from it for instant gratification and a misplaced sense of entitlement? Personally, I know which I’d rather be.

 

Further Information

The following pages contain more information about origami copyright:

The copyright page on the OrigamiUSA website

The Origami Authors and Creators website

The copyright page on Robert Lang’s website

The copyright page on Joseph Wu’s website  (click the copyright link at the bottom of the homepage)

 

The Origami Copyright Logo

The model at the top of this page is an Origami Copyright Sign, designed by Morisue Kei and folded by me.

 

I would love to hear your thoughts on origami copyright – either in the comments below, or you can either contact me on the link at the top of this page. You can also find me on Instagram or Twitter.

You can also subscribe to the mailing list by entering your email in the box below: